Top 27 Real Estate Agents in Columbus

Find the person, find your home.


The Columbus real estate market continues to rapidly grow, with the median home value increasing 15% to $450,000 over the last year. In the coming months, prices are expected to increase. On average, buyers and sellers pay just over 100% of the asking price. The city is known for its vibrant culture and growing tech industry. Farmstead and Grove City are two of the local areas with the highest home values. With a booming employment market and great school districts, Columbus boasts opportunities for young professionals and families. No need to stress about finding the right Realtor. We’ve compiled the highest-rated brokers in the area.

Mike Pacifico

27. Mike Pacifico, RE/MAX

Mike Pacifico is a foundational figure in Ohio’s modern real estate market. He has over 53 years of industry experience and has made a significant impact on what the sector is today. Thousands of customers have successfully completed transactions thanks to Mike’s expertise, generating sales worth several hundred million dollars. He understands the value of a home because he is a family man and has devoted more than 50 years to the cause of assisting others in finding theirs. Although Mike has received numerous awards, he takes the greatest pride in the lifelong clients and friends he has made.

Lorraine Lynn

26. Lorraine Lynn, Corcoran Global Living

Lorraine Lynn is a leading sales and top-producing agent. She is the manager of one of Columbus’s quickest-expanding teams and the go-to person for some of the region’s most dependable top-notch real estate services. By bringing clients to the successful side of their transaction, Lorraine has demonstrated her effectiveness and competence. Many clients come to her because of her expertise in marketing, negotiating, and advertising. Many people in the community that Lorraine adores, calls home, supports, and actively supports rank her in the Top 10% of sales agents in the area.

Amy Clark

25. Amy Clark, LifePoint Real Estate

For more than 20 years, Amy Clark has been one of the Top 20 Agents in the Columbus Board of Realtors. She is a marketing and negotiating prodigy with average annual sales of $42 million. Amy is a distinguished servant leader who works for LifePoint Real Estate under The Clark Group. Numerous agents have benefited from her influence and empowerment to work to the highest ethical and moral standards. Amy won’t work with you merely to buy or sell things for you. She wants your life to get better while getting the best deal for you.

Lari Madosky Shaw

24. Lari Madosky Shaw, Coldwell Bankers Realty

One of the top agents in the nation is Lari Madosky Shaw. She is a leader in Ohio for sales, production, and performance and ranks in the top 1% of all Coldwell Banker agents nationwide. After 27 years in the industry, Lari’s zeal and drive continue to grow as she strives to improve her real estate skills every day. She has worked with over 1,000 families and has extensive real estate experience. Many relocating families have benefited from Lari’s assistance, which has helped make their drastic change a little less overwhelming.

Kurt McCurdy

23. Kurt McCurdy, Howard Hanna

Kurt McCurdy is a Zillow Premier Agent with a five-star rating. His knowledge, expertise, and ability to effectively communicate with clients have all been attested to. He has been in the business for almost 50 years and has assisted countless clients in completing profitable transactions. Kurt has developed the skills necessary to deal with a constantly shifting market because he has seen the changes the company has gone through. He is knowledgeable about all types of structures, including new construction, condos, and historic buildings. Kurt is your best option for anything real estate-related.

Debbie Harr

22. Debbie Harr, Homes That Click

Debbie Harr is an award-winning Ohio realtor. Her peers in the industry hold her in the highest regard and respect. She was listed by Business First as one of the top residential real estate agents in Central Ohio. Debbie closes the best deals for her clients by utilizing all online platforms. She holds herself to a high standard of professionalism, ethics, and excellence. Debbie wants her clients to feel at ease while still respecting their limits. She treats every transaction with the utmost respect, understanding that it affects someone’s future. Debbie cares about you and will help you achieve your objectives.

Nicole Yoder-Barnhart

21. Nicole Yoder-Barnhart, Howard Hanna

Nicole Yoder-Barnhart began working for HER Realtors at the age of 16 and immediately fell in love with real estate. After high school, she pursued real estate studies and became one of Ohio’s youngest licensed real estate agents at the age of 18, according to records. Since then, Nicole has continued to help families realize their real estate goals, whether they are buying, selling, or investing. Her clients benefit from the leverage and partnership with an all-rounder that her experience in all facets of transactions provides. No detail will go unnoticed, and no disked outcome will be compromised while in Nicole’s care.

DeLena Ciamacco

20. DeLena Ciamacco, RE/MAX Connection Realtors

DeLena Ciamacco is a well-known agent who is regarded and esteemed in her field. She has been a professional for 33 years and has held the title of top agent in Ohio for more than 20 years. DeLena has spent more than 20 years ranking among the Top 100 Realtors in the world and as the #1 Agent for Closed Dollar Volume. She specializes in almost all real estate types and has successfully assisted clients in achieving their real estate objectives over the years. DeLena is a true veteran who has made significant contributions to Ohio’s real estate market for a long time.

Charlene Fairman

19. Charlene Fairman, Fairman Founding Partners

With numerous 5-star reviews online, Charlene Fairman is a top-rated real estate agent. She is an expert negotiator and a master communicator. The Real Firm, one of Ohio’s top organizations, was founded and is led by Charlene. She has stuck to her motto of “doing the right thing” throughout the entire process, always acting with integrity and honesty. Among her peers in the area, she is one of the pioneers of using the internet in real estate because she is ambitious and creative. Many people have been motivated by Charlene’s leadership and drive, and as a result, her brokerage is growing and reaching more people.

Sam Cooper

18. Sam Cooper, Howard Hanna

Sam Cooper is a very creative, forward-thinking, and innovative person. He is aware that moving forward and effectively utilizing all available technology is the only option to be able to keep up with the industry. Sam has Ohio’s most popular real estate agent page with the most viewers and followers. His main motivation is to give his customers the best service possible because he believes that’s what they deserve. Condos, brand-new construction, investments, or whatever—he thinks they all deserve the same amount of work, time, and focus. Sam’s partnership gives you market leverage, exposure, connections, and dependability.

Andrew Robinson

17. Andrew Robinson, Real Brokerage Technologies

Andrew Robinson, who graduated from Ohio State University with degrees in economics and marketing, uses his marketing knowledge to identify the most effective strategies for boosting customer loyalty and revenue. He uses technology better than anyone in the industry and produces cutting-edge content to engage audiences. Andrew is a very knowledgeable and skilled realtor. Based on his experience, he will be truthful about the properties you’re interested in, and he always has a good sense of how the housing market is doing. Whether you are buying or selling with Andrew as your realtor, he fights to get the best deal for his clients.

Tracy Keffer

16. Tracy Keffer, Keller Williams Greater Columbus

Among the Top 2% of realtors in Columbus in 2019, Tracy Keffer is regarded as an Expert Realtor in the Columbus and Central Ohio Area. She holds a master’s degree in business administration from Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi and has years of experience working for international marketing and advertising firms. Tracy helps her clients realize their real estate goals with excellent service and dedication. She is a knowledgeable, trustworthy, and professional realtor who gives her all in everything she does. Tracy is an accomplished professional property stager and a steadfast top producer.

Scott Ringer

15. Scott Ringer, Keller Williams Consultants Realty

Scott Ringer is the principal agent and owner of The Ringer Group. They are incredibly knowledgeable about the current market and are true professionals who prioritize the needs of their clients. Scott has 22 years of experience selling homes and has won numerous honors and awards over the years. He has helped some of Columbus’ most well-known figures, and his team provides service to the entire Central Ohio market as well as all nearby suburbs. In his spare time, Scott likes to travel, spend time with his two children, and cheer on the Ohio State Buckeyes.

Carlton J. Shaffer

14. Carlton J. Shaffer, Corcoran Global Living

Because of the clear perspective of his clients and their demands of an agent, Carlton J. Shaffer aspires to excellence. His sole objective is to offer every client the most thorough and knowledgeable service he is capable of. Carlton is a Real Estate Negotiation Expert and a Certified Investor Agent Specialist. For several years running, he has sold millions of dollars worth of real estate, and he keeps improving his methodical approach to marketing and using technology. Carlton wants all of his clients to view him as a member of their family as well as a true professional.

Tina and John Buehler

12. Tina and John Buehler, The Powell Buehler Group

Tina and John Buehler are two of the most successful real estate agents in Central Ohio. With over 100 sales in the past 12 months alone, they have collectively sold nearly 1,700 homes for a total value of $380 million. What’s even more impressive is that Tina and John continue to work with their children and maintain their position as one of the top real estate teams in the business. Over the years, they have received numerous awards such as the Top Sales and Service Award from 2002 to 2020 and a few Multi-Million Dollar Awards from 2001-2020.

Lauren Lucas and Jen Kessel-White

11. Lauren Lucas and Jen Kessel-White, LKW Home Team

Lauren Lucas and Jennifer Kessel-White are two of the most successful real estate agents in Ohio. They first met when they were competing against each other in the field, but they soon discovered how much they complemented each other’s attributes. This led to the creation of the real estate empire KLW Home Team.

The team is recognized as being among the Top 1% of agents in Ohio, with members among the top 100 social media agents in the state. They were also regarded as the Top 10 Agents to Watch Out For in the USA and Canada by Yahoo Finance and Forbes.

Despite their success, Lauren and Jennifer remain grounded and believe in women as powerhouses and the innovative spirit of young minds. That’s why they continue to take the lead in today’s industry.

Diane and Paula Koontz

10. Diane and Paula Koontz, The Koontz Team

Diane Koontz and Paula Koontz are the powerhouse team behind The Koontz Team. With over 86 years of combined real estate experience, they have reached $750 million in sales and sold over 3,000 homes. Both Diane and Paula have achieved the highest sales award in Central Ohio, which is the 25 Million Dollar Award.

What sets Diane and Paula apart from other agents is their dedication to their clients. Diane takes pride in her expertise and believes in treating every client like family, while Paula’s drive for perfection and management skills have earned her a reputation as one of the top-producing brokers in Central Ohio.

Trevor Andrews

9. Trevor Andrews, The Andrews Group

Trevor Andrews has been in the business for nearly 10 years and has been a highly competitive agent. He specializes in both bank-owned properties and traditional sales. Together with a like-minded business partner, he started The Andrews Group. A very powerful two-member team that has helped over 100 clients in 2016 alone. They value their stress-free, honest, and efficient transactions with their clients, and together, they have amassed over $20 million in total sales. But beyond all these Trevor takes pride in his promising record of efficacy in strong communication and honesty with clients – something that is hard to come by in today’s market.

Lori Hicks

8. Lori Hicks, Cbus Agents Group

Lori Hicks has been a real estate agent for over four decades and is considered one of the most experienced and successful agents in Ohio. She’s a member of CBUS Agents, ranked among the Top 1% of agents in Ohio, and has collectively sold over 1,000 homes. With Lori’s expertise in residential properties, new builds, and luxury estates, she’s been a recipient of a number of significant awards, such as the HER Real Living-Silver Award, the HER Real Living- #1 Real Estate Firm in Ohio, and the BIA-MAME Award. Lori is highly regarded due to her dedication and strong work ethic.

Paul George

7. Paul George, Paul George Group

Paul George is a well-known name in the Columbus Board of Realtors, with over 31 years of experience in the industry. He is the founder of The Paul George Group and has consistently ranked among the Top 1% Agent in Columbus. In addition to his success as a real estate agent, Paul is also an Amazon Best Selling Book Author and believes in educating clients to make sure they choose the best option for their needs. He and his family are active volunteers and supporters of Kobacker House, a local care facility in Columbus.

Kathy Chiero

6. Kathy Chiero, The Kathy Chiero Group

Kathy Chiero is a highly experienced real estate agent, with nearly 27 years of experience in the field. She got her start in television and radio, and has also worked as a journalist and public speaker. Kathy is particularly knowledgeable about the real estate market, and she loves to share her expertise with others.

In 2003, Kathy founded Downsize Columbus, which helps thousands of families and homeowners downsize every year. Her natural talent and leadership skills helped her grow the business from scratch into one of the most successful downsizing companies in the country.

Today, Kathy Chiero is the founder and CEO of The Kathy Chiero Group. This team of agents are all honorable members of the National Association of Realtors, and together they’ve helped over 1,200 families find their dream home.

James Roehrenbeck

5. James Roehrenbeck, The Roehrenbeck Group

James Roehrenbeck has been in the real estate business for almost 19 years and is currently with The Roehrenbeck Group. His mission is to provide the best service to his clients with “excellence, honesty, and integrity”. He has a long list of notable awards, including RE/MAX’s Circle of Legends and Hall of Fame, Lifetime Achievement awardee, and a consistent Diamond Club Team awardee from 2018 until 2021. James has been married for over 44 years and has four children as well as 14 grandchildren. He is a reliable family man who also provides excellent real estate services to those in need of finding their dream home.

Ron Kendle

4. Ron Kendle, Kendle Team

Ron Kendle is the owner of the Kendle Team, a group of agents known for their professionalism. They are honored for their honesty, fairness, and consistent feedback of being easy to work with. Ron, with over 21 years of experience and a background in finance and building prior to real estate, is an undeniable expert in his field. He has been inducted into the RE/MAX Hall of Fame and has been a consistent Diamond Club Team awardee from 2019 until 2021. Ron and his family live in New Albany and are active advocates and supporters of the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation, helping the advancement of medical breakthroughs for children with Type 1 diabetes.

Mike Carruthers

3. Mike Carruthers, The Carruthers Team

Mike Carruthers is a real estate veteran of over 28 years. He has been the #1 Top Agent in Coldwell Banker King Thompson Bexley’s office 7 times, and as a member of the Luxury Real Estate Group, his specialty in high-end properties is top-notch. He prides himself on being fair, professional and kind, as his past clients have been quoted. As his slogan goes, “Nobody Knows Bexley Better” – and this is true even beyond luxury; Mike’s expertise covers all your real estate needs. His leadership in The Carruthers Team brought the group to being Coldwell Banker Realty’s Top Listing, Selling, and Closing Agents and the #1 Small Team in the Company’s Bexley Office.

Rhiannon Ferrari

2. Rhiannon Ferrari, Ferrari Home Group

Rhiannon Ferrari is the owner and CEO of Ferrari Home Group, which is in the top 1% of agents in Ohio. The team’s innovative approach to accommodating the needs of clients by utilizing modern platforms and technology secured them the title of Top Team on Social Media in Central Ohio in 2017. With 15 years of experience in the business and an eye for the best, Rhiannon was awarded the prestigious KW Ohio Valley Millionaire Agent Award in 2020. Her expertise assures that when you work with her team, you are guaranteed service that meets or exceeds your expectations whether you are buying, selling, or investing in real estate.

Lee Ritchie

1. Lee Ritchie, Ritchie Realty Group

Lee Ritchie is the founder and head of Ritchie Realty Group, one of the top-performing teams of real estate agents in Columbus, Ohio and the world. With over 2,000 homes sold and over $600 million in total sales, Lee and her team have become experts in the Columbus urban market. With 12 years of experience in real estate, Lee has a wealth of knowledge to share with her clients and makes it her mission to provide them with the best service possible. When she’s not helping people find their dream home, you can find her spending time with her family and friends or cheering on the Buckeyes.